Thursday, September 11, 2008

Michigan Player Chart Week 2

The improvement curve for a first-year coach is always a mystery. There is an adage that states that the biggest improvement occurs between the first and second game of year one. There is also an adage that states that the biggest improvement occurs between the first and second year. If the second adage is true, then the improvement between game one and game two of year one can't be that big—and, it wasn’t. Michigan clearly did some things better but it’s difficult to know how much that had to do with Miami (OH) being much worse than Utah. Even with improvements in the first-half defense and running game, Michigan still did many things that can only be described as atrocious. As a result, there wasn’t a whole lot of movement on the player chart. The top 10 is still dominated by the defense. It’s actually a pretty tall task to come up with 25 players worthy of being ranked at this point. It is my hope that by mid-season, I won’t cringe when I dare to look outside of the top ten. Hopefully, I’ll have a reason to include Carlos Brown next week.



Top 25 Michigan Player Chart (cumulative)














































































































RankPlayerCommentsMovement
1Brandon Graham, DEDestroyed Miami (OH)’s O-line. Forced fumble that was erroneously ruled incomplete. Leads team with 5.5 TFLs and two sacks.

1

2Obi Ezeh, MLBSolid effort against Miami (OH) after Big Ten D-Player of Week in week one. 5 tackles, a pass break up and a fumble recovery.

1

3Brandon Harrison, SMichigan’s defensive MVP in game two. Saved a touchdown, broke up another pass, pressured the QB and made solid tackles.

6

4Morgan Trent, CBStellar other than getting beat on a deep ball and committing a bad P.I. penalty.

5Donovan Warren, CBExcellent game. Could’ve had two picks. Punt returns need work.

5

6Tim Jamison, DEGood pressure on QB, made solid tackles, and saved a TD by forcing an early throw.

1

7Will Johnson, DTNot as spectacular as game one but was otherwise solid.

4

8Sam McGuffie, RBSpent game alternating sweet runs with getting annihilated at the line of scrimmage. Led team with 106 total yards. Sweet YPC until last drive.

3

9Terrance Taylor, DTI think his best is yet to come. Played pretty well in first two games.

2

10Greg Mathews, WRDNP. First game was a very good all-around effort.

4

11Michael Shaw, RBLeft game after two splendid carries for 45 yards in the first quarter.

2

12Montavious Odoms, WRStarted off game with a brilliant catch and run for 50 yards.

2

13John Thompson, LBNoble effort in first start of season. Led the team in tackles and had a TFL. Aggressive tackles. Upgrade over Panter.

N/A

14Jonas Mouton, LBVery quick to the ball against Miami (OH). Noticeably better than Marell Evans.

7

15Mike Martin, DTVery good in limited action. Quicker than most DTs. Picked up a TFL in second straight game.

4

16Zoltan Mesko, PSolid for second straight game. Although, it would be nice if he outperformed the other team’s punter every once in a while.

17Brandon Minor, RBSpectacular TD run on only carry against Miami (OH).

18Junior Hemingway, WRZero catches to go along with some nice downfield blocking against Miami (OH)

10

19Steven Threet, QBTerrible passer but ran for 36 yards in roughly a quarter. Would’ve benefited from more QB-run plays.

3

20Carson Butler, TEZero catches. I feel bad for him. It’s disappointing that ‘M’ coaches aren't looking to him more considering inept passing game.

5

21K.C. Lopata, KMissed extra-point and missed 41 yard field goal are unacceptable.

9

22Ryan Van Bergen, DESolid again in limited action.

2

23Steve Schilling, OTBest O-lineman. Running game was better against Miami (OH) for what that’s worth.

N/A

24Charles Stewart, SSlightly better than Stevie Brown so far.

N/A

25Stevie Brown, SPlays too much not to be in the top 25. Needs to start making reads and plays.

N/A

Tuesday, September 09, 2008

Observations on Miami (OH) Game

  • The Michigan defense was awful in the first half against Utah. If there was one thing Michigan fans could be sure about heading into the season, it was that the defense was going to be good. At halftime of the Utah game, I bet half of the fans across the country wanted to puke. I know I did. Fortunately, the days of warding off puking should be over. The Michigan defense is, in fact, very good. In its last six quarters, the defense has given up just three points and a scant 280 yards.

  • After two games, there is only one noticeable difference between Steven Threet and Nick Sheridan. Both are absurdly bad passers. Both play incredibly stiff. Both are slow. However, Threet does a much better job of finding running lanes and then accelerating through those lanes. Neither QB is good enough to play exclusively but in a tight race, the tie goes to the guy who can actually do something. Threet ran for 36 yards on four carries in just over a quarter. Mysteriously, Threet never attempted another rush after the 14:44 mark of the second quarter. I have no explanation especially since any semblance of running ability by the QB quintuples the effectiveness of the spread.

  • The good news is that Tate Forcier (or Shavodrick Beaver) is going to blow up in this offense. There were so many running lanes for Michigan quarterbacks against Miami (OH) that Michigan could’ve put up 300 yards rushing rather easily with a mobile QB. Without the fear of having the QB take off, opposing defenses have the luxury of focusing almost entirely on the running back. Next year, it’s on! Get excited.

  • It’s amazing to think that just a month ago, Brandon Harrison and Charles Stewart were mired in a position battle at strong safety. Harrison has been dynamite in Michigan’s first two games. He saved a sure touchdown by knocking the ball out of a receiver’s hands in the end zone. He broke up another pass with great positioning that wasn’t pass interference despite Andre Ware’s objections. He was also very good tackling in the open field. I’m not sure many people saw this coming. I know I didn’t.

  • With Harrison’s emergence, Michigan’s secondary now consists of ¾ hot fudge brownie sundae (heaven in a bowl) and ¼ fruit cake (not so much). Steve Brown doesn’t have a lot of experience. He certainly could develop into a capable player. However, right now, he isn’t very good. Rich Rodriguez prefers to talk about the positive and I certainly don’t blame him for that. Unfortunately, Brown has been on the wrong end of a number of bad plays making the “positive” consist of “he has athletic ability and flies around out there”. Not exactly an endorsement of his actual contributions. With Austin Panter and Marell Evans coming out of the lineup after week one, Brown is easily the weak link on defense. I don’t think Michigan has the equivalent of John Thompson and Jonas Mouton to plug in for Brown. Hopefully he gets things together.

  • Donovan Warren has been very good—as a cornerback. I’m not sure if I’ve ever seen a worse first-step from of a punt returner, though. Warren’s best asset is that he holds on to the ball which is clearly an important attribute for a kick returner. There has to be a better option. Warren seems to hesitate for a split second which is a split second too long. By the time he makes his decision, the coverage is in his face. Michigan needs to find someone who catches and goes without mentally typing a 10-page paper on which direction is the best to run. Plus, it’s disheartening to see your All-American caliber CB unnecessarily blasted five times per game when nothing comes of it.

  • A lot has been made of Rich Rodriguez’s implementation of the spread with a roster that isn’t exactly conducive for such an offense. What people might not be thinking about is the sheer horror that we would be seeing right now from Lloyd Carr. The spread—despite the absence of a spread QB—is actually protecting Michigan because there aren’t any sacks. Michigan has only been sacked three times in two games for a meager total of seven yards. The offensive line has been brutal but Rodriguez neutralizes things by having an offense based on misdirection and quick decisions. Under the hold coaching staff, Ryan Mallet or Steven Threet or whoever would be getting killed with this offensive line.

  • Michigan might have only scored 16 points against Miami but Rodriguez deserves credit for about 37. Threet badly missed would-be touchdowns to open receivers on four occasions. Two were on the same drive. Those are throws that even the worst I-AA QBs need to be able to complete. If Threet doesn’t start making those throws, Michigan will have a hard time beating any team with even a remotely good offense.

  • Threet not only missed four touchdowns with terrible throws, he also failed to complete even a single pass more than two yards beyond the line of scrimmage. That’s just brutal. In fact, Michigan’s strength right now should be throwing down field. Neither QB is equipped to run with the ball. If they can’t throw either, then why not line up Carlos Brown behind center and run every play. Seriously.

  • Miami was almost as bad in the passing game. Miami receivers dropped a touchdown and four first downs. Daniel Raudabaugh also overthrew two wide open receivers on sure-fire touchdowns.

  • Steve Brown was pretty bad on Saturday but he did provide quite possibly the best moment of the day. He yanked down Thomas Merriweather by his dreads. More players should use this play.

  • I have never seen a redo in college football that didn’t involve a penalty. In fact, I’m pretty sure they don’t exist. Dave Pasch and Andre Ware erroneously told the viewing audience that the refs had ruled that an inadvertent whistle had been blown before the snap causing a do-over. However, if you have the luxury of DVR, it was obvious that there was no such whistle. I believe that the refs made up their own rule. They initially ruled the play down with a whistle and then upon discussion, came to the conclusion that the play should not have been ruled an incomplete pass but rather a fumble. So, to cover their arses, they said there should be a do-over. Unfortunately, once the whistle was blown, the play is over. They can’t use replay and they can’t use a do-over.

  • Jonas Mouton played very well. He was quick to the ball and made aggressive hits. He has the potential to be a playmaker. I expect he’ll have some bad moments since there was a reason Marell Evans won the starting job coming out of fall practice. Still, Mouton and John Thompson were a substantial upgrade from Evans and Austin Panter.

  • For the second straight week, Zoltan Mesko punted pretty well but was blown out of the stadium by the opposing punter. Mesko punted seven times for 318 yards for an average of 45.4 yards. That is good for an ordinary human being but not for Punter God II Jacob Richardson. The holy punter booted seven punts for 377 yards for a whopping average of 54 yards. Mesko has been pretty good on the season with 14 punts for 582 yards for a 41.6 average. However, we may have just seen the greatest back to back punting performances by Michigan opponents in the history of the program. Punter God I (Utah’s Louie Sakoda) and Punter God II combined to boot 13 punts for 659 yards for a 51 yard average. Amazing.

  • Go Blue!

Thursday, September 04, 2008

Michigan Player Chart Week 1

I thought it might be cool to track the progress of Michigan's best players throughout the season. Instead of the typical top 25 college football poll, I'll be doing a weekly top 25 Michigan player poll. My rankings won't be based as much on reputation and potential as they will be on actual game-performance. Carson Butler is probably one of the five most talented players on the team but if nobody throws to him, he'll have a hard time cracking the top ten. The rankings will be cumulative each week. By mid-season, player movement should be fairly limited. I expect substantial movement after week two. There were a lot of terrible performances. The defense dominates the list since the offense was putrid.

I was able to watch the Utah-game twice; once in person and once on DVR. I plan on viewing each game at least twice so I'm not saying stupid things like, "Marell Evans was phenomenal with 4 tackles and .5 TFLs." It obviously doesn't apply this week but I'll add a movement column to track player movement from week to week.

Quick side note: This is slightly off topic but I'm pretty fired up about it. Greg Mathews was injured because #11 on Utah was an idiot and dove onto Mathews's leg after the ball was dropped. That joker should've been given a late hit penalty. I noticed it at the game and it was just as ridiculous when I took another look at home. As a result, Mathews will likely be out this week. It's a shame because Mathews was Michigan's best player on offense.



Top 25 Michigan Player Chart














































































































RankPlayerComments
1 Obi Ezeh, MLB Big Ten Defensive Player of the Week.
2Brandon Graham, DEHeated up on the last drive of first half. Finished with 3.5 TFL, 1 sack, and 7 tackles.
3Will Johnson, DTSingled out by Rodriguez along with Ezeh. Finished with 1.5 sacks.
4Morgan Trent, CBFlawless with quite a few authoritative hits.
5Tim Jamison, DETwo tackles, two sacks.
6Greg Mathews, WRMade two fantastic defensive plays; one prevented an int., the other a possible TD. Also led ‘M’ with 54 total yards.
7Terrance Taylor, DTRode the bench for a bit in the 2nd Half but chipped in with a blocked extra point, 3 tackles, and .5 sacks.
8Junior Hemingway, WRNice grab on 3rd and 5 in traffic and, of course, the 33 yard TD grab.
9Brandon Harrison, SSurprisingly solid day. Two pretty good kick returns combined with good position all day made for a good effort.
10Donovan Warren, CBTwo horrible plays; one led to a 55 yard pass completion and the other went for a TD. He was solid otherwise.
11Sam McGuffie, RBNo room to run but ran for a TD and hauled in a 23 yard pass.
12K.C. Lopata, KIncreased his career long by eight yards with a 50 yard field goal.
13Michael Shaw, RBSimilar to McGuffie but had 20 fewer total yards. Hauled in a nice 8-yard TD grab.
14Montavious Odoms, WRHauled in the nicest -3 yard reception you’ll ever see. Had little room to operate but showed great hands with five catches.
15Carson Butler, TEQuiet for most of the day. Made a fantastic one-handed catch on 3rd down drive that led to a TD. He should get 15 looks a game.
16Zoltan Mesko, PNothing like Utah’s punter God. One bad punt overshadowed an otherwise solid effort. He was busy booting 7 punts for 264 yards.
17Brandon Minor, RBHad one carry for 21 yards and three other carries for zero yards. Should’ve had a TD grab but was badly overthrown.
18Austin Panter, LBHe was involved in a lot of plays; good and bad. 4 tackles, .5 sacks and a fumble recovery is a decent tow even with a few misreads.
19Mike Martin, DTSpelled Taylor for parts of the second half and the defense didn’t miss a beat.
20Ryan Van Bergen, DEBefore leaving with an injury, provided good pressure and forced an intentional grounding penalty.
21Jonas Mouton, LBPlayed better than Marell Evans.
22Steven Threet, QBNice TD pass to Hemingway and did well at getting out of the pocket. Accuracy was pretty brutal.
23Adam Patterson, DENot too many players worthy of mentioning left but Patterson had a tackle and a forced fumble that gave ‘M’ a chance to tie.
24Mark Moundros, FBBlocked punt was huge.
25Darryl Stonum, WRNot much to say. He was wide open on 4th down and could’ve kept Michigan’s hopes alive but…you know the rest.


Tuesday, September 02, 2008

Observations on Michigan's Opener

  • If my level of enthusiasm was a ten (scale of 1-10) before the Utah game, my level of enthusiasm is still a ten. Normally, a Michigan loss in the opener (usually a game that Michigan should have or could have won) would destroy my enthusiasm for the season. This one did not. I’ve never been more pumped for a MAC opponent in my life. Bring on the RedHawks!

  • There is an article on “The Wolverine” titled, “Expectations tempered after opener”. This would imply that expectations were that Michigan would beat Utah and be amazing with a new coach, a new system, a walk-on QB, three true freshmen starters, and a weak offensive line. If you foolishly ignored those things, then yes, you’ll need to now ratchet down the expectations a bit. You’ll also probably want to lower your expectations on winning the lottery and marrying a member of Brangelina. For everyone else, no adjustment is necessary. This team is capable of anything and nothing. I sense we’ll get a little of both this year. Enjoy the ride. This is the year where it’s OK for Michigan to lose. Take advantage of it.

  • I was disappointed in Rich Rodriguez for mainly two things on Saturday. One is more forgivable than the other. I don’t understand how he could watch Nick Sheridan and Steven Threet for weeks in practice and come to the conclusion that Sheridan was the better player. Threet was a four-star, highly recruited QB, who played magnificently in high school. Sheridan was a walk-on QB who played seven games in high school and was far from magnificent. Side note: The dude sitting in front of me at the game on Saturday said that he watched all of Sheridan’s games at Saline and he wasn’t very good. That doesn’t guarantee that Threet is the better option but it should at least be a giant, zeppelin-esque clue. It might have been an illusion, but Threet even looked to be the better scrambler and possibly the faster runner. Sheridan was terrible. He looked as bad as you would expect a walk-on to look. However, I do understand that there exists “practice stars”. We’ve seen them time and time again at Michigan (Chris Graham, Markus Curry etc.). Without game speed, it’s hard to judge how players will perform in actual games. This was obviously the case with Sheridan. Rodriguez saw Sheridan do well in practice, took it at face value, and named him the starter. I wish he would’ve seen the glaring difference in ability but he saw something in Sheridan and that’s somewhat understandable.

    What isn’t understandable in the slightest is how long Rodriguez stuck with Sheridan. That very likely cost UM the game. Before the game—58 minutes before the game, in the stadium, under the relentless sun, to be exact—Nick and I made predictions about when Threet would come into the game. I’m pretty sure we both agreed that it would be around the fourth series unless Sheridan was just flawless. The fact that Sheridan was awful and still made it eight series before being yanked is inexcusable. I’m guessing that Rodriguez was somewhat tricked or hamstrung (however way you want to look at it) by Michigan’s 10 points. Those who watched the game know better. Sheridan mustered a total of 35 yards on those 10 points. Utah pretty much forked them over on a platter of turnovers and penalties. Michigan should’ve been shutout in the first half and the fact that it wasn’t is what kept Sheridan in the game far too long.

  • Michigan will need to improve dramatically in the intermediate passing game to have a chance at a successful season. Michigan’s best passing threat came in the form of pass interference calls against Utah. Judging from the first game, it seems like 10-15 yard routes are not a part of Rodriguez’s offense. That will need to change. Your passing game can’t simply be to throw up a “jump ball” deep or throw a swing pass every other attempt. When it came time for Threet and Co. to drive down the field to win the game, they had nothing to lean on. Michigan has the receivers and the QBs to abuse corners and linebackers on basic passing routes. That advantage needs to be used. Smart Football has an article that discusses this a little deeper. Also, Rodriguez might want to think about throwing it to Carson Butler every other play. He shouldn't have to wait until he's in the NFL before he becomes a star.

  • When the defense got rollin’ in the second half and the scores started to pile up, the stadium was loud—really loud. In fact, it was probably the loudest I have heard the stadium with the possible exception of the pandemonium that ensued after Charles Woodson’s punt return against OSU in 1997. The crowd did its part. Utah’s offense was clearly out of sync once the crowd got into it. The defense had a little something to do with that, too.

  • The defense looked terrible in the first half but was dominating in the second. Your guess is as good as mine as to which one will show up for the remainder of the season. Odds are we’ll get a little of both. However, the cornerbacks and defensive line were outstanding. Morgan Trent and Donovan Warren are easily one of the five best cornerback tandems in the country. I’m also pretty sure that the d-line is among the ten best in the country. This defense is very close to being incredible.

  • Utah is a good team. The Utes were ranked in the preseason poll. They were expected to be good and they are. They aren’t a great team but this wasn’t Appalachian St. or even Utah ’02. Utah turned out to be too good of an opening opponent. If the dates of the Utah and Miami (OH) games were switched, then maybe Michigan starts off 2-0.

  • Never in a million years would I engage in a conversation on a message board. I cherish my sanity too much. However, I do like to read them to gauge reactions. The number of people who have already given up on Michigan this season and Rodriguez for the long haul amazes me. Don’t get me wrong, these people are idiots. They are in the minority. But, how anyone could expect anything this season is beyond me. By any definition, this was always going to be a rebuilding season. The real questions were based on how bad things would get. I haven’t seen anything to indicate Michigan won’t get to a bowl which was always the goal this season. Side note: not all message board posters are bad. In fact, most aren't.

  • The halftime adjustments were amazing for the simple fact that there actually were some. The Michigan coaches corrected the defense in a hurry.

  • That old Michigan comeback magic didn’t die with the spread. Threet led a commendable comeback attempt and it was great to see the team fight back. That is encouraging. Just think how much press UCLA got for coming back against Tennessee after playing so poorly early. Kevin Craft had one of the worst halves in football history and still managed to become the lead story on ESPN.com after leading UCLA back to a victory. Michigan and Threet were a missed two-point conversation from having that reality.

  • Speaking of the UCLA/Tennessee game. Did you see UCLA’s kickoff after taking the lead with 30 seconds to go? Rick Neuheisel opted for the high, short kickoff which is OK if there’s three seconds left or if you’re up by more than three points. That decision nearly cost UCLA the game. Even still, that decision left Tennessee 20 yards from a game-tying field goal that it would eventually make to force overtime. Luckily for Neuheisel, his team pulled it off in OT. Had UCLA lost that game, he should have forfeited his game check.

  • Go Blue!

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Resume breakdown of U.S. and China

Before I get started with the medal-breakdown, you may notice that my medal-count differs slightly from the “official” medal count that you might find on ESPN.com or NBC.com. I refuse to acknowledge the medals that China won in events in which it cheated. Three members of the Chinese women’s gymnastics team are under the age of 16. He Kexin, Jian Yuyuan, and Yang Yilin accounted for two gold and two bronze medals. So, I have removed two gold and two bronze medals from China’s medal-count. I have also added two gold medals to the U.S.-count since it won the silver in the two events in which China cheated. I have also subtracted two silver medals from the U.S.-count since those turn into gold.

Refer to the guide below if you want to quickly calculate the non-cheating medal count. Simply take the “official medal count” and make the following amendments…


Cheating Adjustments
















CountryGoldSilverBronzeTotal
U.S.+2-200
China-20-2-4




The U.S. has been the undisputed king of the summer games ever since the collapse of the Soviet Union and the subsequent dismantling of the short-lived Unified Team after the ’92 Olympics. There is a good chance that streak will continue in Beijing as the Americans have been atop the medals-leaderboard since Day 1. However, that isn’t a given because the U.S.’s lead is tenuous. China has been on the U.S.’s tail from Day 1. China’s assault on medals—gold especially—is incredible considering the fact that it only tallied 63 medals—32 of which were gold—in 2004 Games in Athens. With four days to go in Beijing, China already has 79 medals, 45 of which are gold. Give a country with 1.3 billion people eight years to get ready for something, and chances are something good is going to happen. I’m not sure there’s any other way of looking at it.

Even though China has been very good, the U.S. has been its usual brilliant self. Russia has been the primary victim of China’s success. It had 92 medals in ’04 but only has 45 in Beijing. The U.S. has seen its fair share of disappointments as is the case at virtually every Olympics. Remember the catastrophic headlines from the 2006 Winter Games in Torino when Bode Miller didn’t win five gold medals? Well, expect to hear some of that same treatment as a result of the U.S.’s underwhelming display in track & field. Justin Gatlin’s four-year ban and the sudden and shocking rise to prominence of Jamaica’s track team is the main culprit here. However, let's not get carried away with the negativity. The U.S. currently boasts 14 medals from track & field--six more than any other country--with more sure to come. Look for the U.S. to take the gold and silver in the Men's 400 m. The track team lost a sure gold medal when Lolo Jones, who was a mere three seconds from easily winning gold in the 100 m hurdles, tripped on the second to last hurdle.

America's team sports have been outstanding. It has seen its best indoor volleyball showing (men and women’s) in years. Both water polo teams have been outstanding. Both men and women’s beach volleyball has been outstanding as usual. The men and women’s basketball teams have dominated. Women’s softball has been unstoppable. The women’s soccer team has found its way back into the gold medal game. Even the vaunted Gymnastics team won gold in non-cheating gymnastics.

I was curious to see how the U.S. stacked up against China in a comparison of resumes. The U.S. has the most medals. China has the most “golds.” Which one is more impressive? A gold medal is clearly more valuable than a silver medal and a silver medal is obviously more valuable than a bronze medal. The difference between gold and silver and silver and bronze is often razor-thin. So, I decided to compare the U.S. and China on a simple points-based system that awards three points for a gold, two points for a silver, and one point for a bronze.

Below is a chart comparing the U.S. and China in the non-cheating medal count and a simple point based system (Gold=3, Silver=2, Bronze=1)…

















CountryGoldSilverBronzeTotalPoints
U.S.28262882164
China43141872175




China’s robust gold-count is quite impressive. The U.S. holds the overall medal-lead but, at this point, China’s resume is more impressive per overall points. The U.S. only trails by eleven points which is a fairly small deficit. Both countries have been outstanding and it’s going to be fun to see who ends up on top. Hopefully the U.S. can make it four-consecutive Summer Olympics leading the medal-count.

The U.S. also has an opportunity to surpass its medal-count from the ’04-Olympics. It’s going to be close.

















CountryGoldSilverBronzeTotalPoints
U.S. ‘0828242779159
U.S. ‘04363927102213




I will be on hiatus until the first week of September. Enjoy the rest of the Olympics and good luck fighting off the anticipation of college football!
 

Powered by Blogger